All roads lead back to Gold
CHANGE CURRENCY:

How to Govern When No One Agrees

Original Analysis | SchiffGold | 20 Nov, 2026

A core premise shared by many different schools of modern political thought is that governance derives its validity from the will of the people. While this belief allows us to avoid answering more fundamental questions about the purpose of government, it makes it much more difficult to ground policy, as the will of the people is often fractured, contradictory, and changes over time. One school of thought believes that direct democracy is the standard for government, and even if not direct, all governance must strive to live up to the standard of direct democracy. Another school of thought believes that some things are too fundamental to leave up to democratic control, and that they must be protective, even as other regulations could be voted on democratically. Another school of thought thinks that any form of government where the people have meaningful control is inherently unstable, and the best that we can do is manage institutional decay, or remove the autonomy of the people. These schools of thought have answered this paradox in different ways, and each of them is important to understanding the future of governance and the complex dynamics that regulate our daily lives. 

The school of thought that is friendly to pure democracy is able to dissipate populist energy effectively while encountering great risks to structural stability. No limits on what the people can choose to do will create wealth redistribution and ill-advised central control for most industries unless the people are uniquely wise and self-controlled. This form of governance does let the will of the people be directly translated to policy, but the size of most societies means that this must be through some form of mediation. This method of pure democracy is rarely created institutionally, but it often exists functionally, as the people vote for leaders that they know will steamroll the governmental barriers put in place by law or constitution. A nation cannot persist on popular energy alone, and the problem with this form of government is that it often leads to the destruction of the nation itself, as the people often lack the information needed to understand which governance choices would be best for them.…

civic virtue constitutional government democracy direct democracy Federalism government power human nature Individual Liberty limited government political philosophy popular sovereignty rule of law separation of powers